March 2015, № 3 (178)

Letuta T.V. ALTERNATIVE WAYS OF CIVIL DISPUTE RESOLUTION IN ORENBURG REGION: HISTORY AND DEVELOPMENT PROSPECTS Historical aspects of arbitration, verbal and conscience courts in Orenburg region are described from the time of government's official formation. Possible background of such courts formation and examples of its practice are considered on the basis of archival materials. A certain similarity in the methods of dispute resolution is observed. Statistical analysis of general jurisdiction court in Orenburg region, arbitration court of Orenburg region as well as courts' practice of Samara region and Kazakhstan Republic allowed finding out a low demand for conciliation and arbitration proceedings at the present time. Presumable reasons for nonoccurrence of alternative way of dispute resolution in pre-revolutionary and modern Russia are presented. A general analysis of proposed changes in draft law concerning arbitration courts in Russian Federation in comparison with pre-revolutionary legislation (according it an arbitration court decision was enforced on a regular basis) is carried out. It is offered to give a special consideration to the legislation of Kazakhstan Republic regarding alternative methods of dispute resolution, whereas historical trade between Asian and Russian merchants had particular importance. Author formed conclusion concerning necessity of government control displacement, proposed in draft law, from the moment of arbitration institution's formation and arbitration proceedings to the stage of obtaining the status of arbitrator. It is claimed that draft law does not consider the historical aspect in legal regulation of alternative ways for dispute resolution in Russian pre-revolutionary and Soviet legislation. The paper suggested that regional arbitration courts will not be developed appropriately in case of legislative control's hardening by state on the stage of arbitration institution formation and during the arbitration proceedings. Key words: arbitration court, mediation, judicial practice, legislation reforming.

Download

References:

1. Bulyakov I.I. Bashkir lands as part of Orenburg region (XVIII century) // http://www.vipstd.ru/nauteh/index.php/--gn13-03/810-a

2. Vicin A.I. Arbitration court specializing in Russian law //http://arbitrage.spb.ru/jts/2000/6/art08.html

3. Volin A.A. Resolution of economic disputes by arbitration court. — M. — 1962. — 50 p.

4. Volkov A.F. Arbitration court in Ancient Russia // http://arbitrage.spb.ru/jts/2000/4/art04.html

5. Voropanov V.A. Judicial body as social evolution factor in Orenburg region (1775-1866) — Chelyabinsk. — 2001.- 292 p.

6. Voropanov V.A. Practice of conscience courts in Ural and West Siberia at the end of XVIII — first half of XIX century // Scientific reporter of Ural state service academy: politology, sociology, economics, law. — 2010. — №2(11) // http://vestnik.uapa.ru/ru/issue/2010/02/21/

7. Dzhanshiev G. Period of great reforms: book 2. М. 2008 (Series "University library of Alexandr Pogorelskiy"). — 496 p. Printed according to publication of Dzhanshiev G. Period of great reforms: historical notes. St. Petersburg. 1905.

8. Emelyanov V., Biryukova V. Orenburg Themis. — Orenburg. — 2007. — 189 p.

9. Emelyanov V.A., Kupchik V.K. In the name of state. Historical sketches about judicial system of Orenburg region — Orenburg. — 2008. — 400 p.

10. History of Russian mediation development // http://profmediacia.ru/index/istorija_razvitija_mediacii_v_rossii/0-67

11. Miklashevskiy А. Arbitration and agreement in industrial disputes. Yuriyev-Derpt. 1907. 104 p.

12. Mikheev R., Koidzumi Е., Morozov N. Criminality and legal culture // http://gov.cap.ru/SiteMap.aspx?gov_id=25'amp;id=144440

13. Morozov М. E. Specifics of culture's influence on arbitration proceedings // Arbitration court. — 2010. — №2. — P.153 — 162.

14. Complete collection of Russian Empire laws. [Collection 1]. — St. Petersburg. — 1830. Book 14. — № 10222. — P. 66-68 // http://www.nlr.ru/e-res/law_r/search.php

15. Resolution of USSR Ministers Council from July 23, 1959 "About improvement of state arbitration" // USSR Set of rules. — 1959. — №15.

16. Law book of Russian Empire // http://civil.consultant.ru/reprint/books/238/

17. Skvorcov О.Y. Arbitration proceedings in Russia. Problems. Trends. Perspectives. — Wolters Kluwer Russia, 2005. — 691 // http://books.google.ru/books?id=ORQY0JAL63wC'amp;pg=PA41'amp;hl=ru'amp;source=gbs_toc_r'amp;cad=2#v=onepage'amp;q'amp;f=false

18. Council code 1649. — М. — 1961 // http://www.hist.msu.ru/ER/Etext/1649/15.htm

19. Encyclopedic dictionary / edited by Andreevskiy I.E., Arsenyev К.К., Petrushevskiy F.F. — St. Petersburg: publ. Brockhauz F.А., Efron I.А. — 1890-1907 // http://www.vehi.net/brokgauz/

About this article

Author: Letuta T.V.

Year: 2015

Editor-in-chief

Sergey Aleksandrovich
MIROSHNIKOV

© Электронное периодическое издание: ВЕСТНИК ОГУ on-line (VESTNIK OSU on-line), ISSN on-line 1814-6465
Зарегистрировано в Федеральной службе по надзору в сфере связи, информационных технологий и массовых коммуникаций
Свидетельство о регистрации СМИ: Эл № ФС77-37678 от 29 сентября 2009 г.
Учредитель: Оренбургский государственный университет (ОГУ)
Главный редактор: С.А. Мирошников
Адрес редакции: 460018, г. Оренбург, проспект Победы, д. 13, к. 2335
Тел./факс: (3532)37-27-78 E-mail: vestnik@mail.osu.ru