Volosova N. SOME DISCUSSION ABOUT THE CLERIC'S SEAL OF CONFESSION AND WITNESS IMMUNITY IN CRIMINAL PROCEDURE.In the article is considered the issue of cleric participation regulation in criminal-procedural relations and his lodgment of witness immunity. The author concludes that current procedural law regulates the problem inconsistently, without taking present time realis into consideration. Particularly, it is emphasized, that not all creeds have sacrament of communion and therefore the seal of confession. The author also reveals other legislative lacunas, which it is offered to solve through respective amendments to article 56 of CPC RF. Key words: the seal of confession, cleric's witness immunity, refusal to testify, religious organizations.
References:
1. Bernardi J. E. De l"origine et des proqres de la legislation fracais ou histoire du doit public et prive de la France, depuis la foundation de la monarchie gusque et compris la revolution. Paris, 1816.
2. Budnikov V. Witness immunity in criminal procedure {Text}: lecture / V. Budnikov. — Volgograd: Volgograd State University publishing house, 1998.
3. Hegel G.W.F. Works of different time: two-volume edition / A. Guliga's prolusion. — M., 1970-1971. — 1 volume.
4. Darmanin A.: Psychology and religion. Melita Theologica, 1988, Vol.39 (2).
5. De Salvia, M. Precedents of European Court on Human Rights. Rudders of court practice concerning European convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. 1960-2002 court practice / M. de Salvia. — Saint-Petersburg: publishing house "Juridical center Press", 2004.
6. Evseenko V. The seal of confession in Russian criminal procedure. / International practical journal "Society and law". 2014. # 2.
7. Korolev G. The seal of confession in criminal procedure // Russian Justice. 1995. # 2.
8. Koni A. Eight-volume collection works. — M., 1967. — 4th volume.
9. Kipnis N. Admissibility of evidence in criminal procedure / Editor in chief P. Lupinskaya. M.: Jurist, 1995.
10. Lenski, G., The religious factor, Garden City, N. Y.: Doubleday, 1961.
11. Makarova Z. Criminal procedure publicity: conceptions and development problems: doctor of legal sciences thesis. — Ekaterinburg, 1996.
12. Melnikov V. Witness in Russian criminal procedure // Legal practice. 2011. # 2.
13. Fundamentals of Russian Orthodox Church social conception // Informational bulletin. Department for External Church Relations of Moscow Patriarchate. 2000. N 8. P. 52, 53.
14. Plato. Three-volume works edition. — M., 1968. — 1st volume.
15. Pchelintsev A. If the seal of confession perfect. / Legislation and economics. 2011. N 5.
16. Russian Federation. Laws. Religious freedom and religious organizations act: national law {adopted by State Duma in 19th of September 1997: accepted by the Council of the Federation in 24th September 1997} // Collection of Legislative Acts of the Russian Federation. — 1997. — N 39. — article 4465.
17. Russian law of the X-XX centuries in 9 volumes / edited by B. Vilenskii. — M.: Juridicheskaya literature, 1991 — 6th volume.
18. Information portal "Religion and mass media" // {Electronic resource}: — Access mode: www.religare.ru.
19. Tatyanin D., Zakirova L. The seal of confession issue in Russian criminal procedure // Orenburg State University Bulletin. 2011. # 3.
20. Tomin V. Russian criminal procedure. Problem lectures: textbook (for students of juridical high schools) / Science editor V. Tomin, A. Popov, I. Zinchenko. — Pyatigorsk: publishing house "RIA-KMV", 2014.
21. Criminal procedure: textbook / under the general editorship of P. Lupinckaya. — M., 2009.
22. Frantsifirov Y. Criminal procedure contradictions: abstract from doctor of legal sciences thesis. — Nizhny Novgorod, 2007.
About this article
Author: Volosova N.Yu.
Year: 2015
|